Yeah, Melinda Duckett killed the baby. [Archive]

View Full Version : Yeah, Melinda Duckett killed the baby.

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 05:37 PM

Remember the woman who appeared on Nancy Grace and then killed herself, then Grace got crucified for "abusing" that "poor woman"? Well, it's out now that Duckett was the primary suspect, she always had been, and it's been revealed today that the bitch not only repainted Trenton's room, but also had thrown away unused diapers, his toybox, and pictures of him in the days following the disappearance while she was under surveillance. Selfish, piece of shit cunt.

Judge Smails

09-20-2006, 05:50 PM

Maybe a Dingo ate her baby.

HBox

09-20-2006, 05:51 PM

And I'm sure Nancy Grace knew all this and didn't just assume she was guilty and go for the sensationalistic angle consequences be damned. She knew she was guilty, had the evidence, and she went after a woman who had just lost her child for whatever reason out of a sense of justice, not a shameless ratings grab. What am I saying, Grace knew she was guilty and was just eviscerating this woman because she knows all at all times. She's a hero, not a perverse cunt who gets off on being judge jury and exectuioner.

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 05:54 PM

HBox wrote: And I'm sure Nancy Grace knew all this and didn't just assume she was guilty and go for the sensationalistic angle consequences be damned. She knew she was guilty, had the evidence, and she went after a woman who had just lost her child for whatever reason out of a sense of justice, not a shameless ratings grab. What am I saying, Grace knew she was guilty and was just eviscerating this woman because she knows all at all times. She's a hero, not a perverse cunt who gets off on being judge jury and exectuioner.   News organizations and journalists usually have "inside" information that's not for public consumption.  For example, it was a well-known fact that McGreevey was gay before he came out with the NJ news media.   I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if a police source tipped off to Grace or Grace's staff that she was the lone, primary suspect.

HBox

09-20-2006, 05:56 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: HBox wrote: And I'm sure Nancy Grace knew all this and didn't just assume she was guilty and go for the sensationalistic angle consequences be damned. She knew she was guilty, had the evidence, and she went after a woman who had just lost her child for whatever reason out of a sense of justice, not a shameless ratings grab. What am I saying, Grace knew she was guilty and was just eviscerating this woman because she knows all at all times. She's a hero, not a perverse cunt who gets off on being judge jury and exectuioner. News organizations and journalists usually have "inside" information that's not for public consumption. For example, it was a well-known fact that McGreevey was gay before he came out with the NJ news media. I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if a police source tipped off to Grace or Grace's staff that she was the lone, primary suspect. I guess that makes it ethical and OK.<img width="239" height="277" border="0" src="http://www.cnn.com/US/9707/olympic.park.bombing/wrong.man/jewell.final.jpg" /> Oh wait, no it doesn't. And I highly doubt that anyone is talking to blabbermouth nancy grace. 

This message was edited by HBox on 9-20-06 @ 9:57 PM

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 05:59 PM

To be honest, I've never watched Grace's show.  But I didn't see the issue with her line of questioning.  It's very simple - what stores did she go to?  Where did she go?  Melinda had a snippy attitude as well.  Don't act like Melinda was sobbing on the phone and Grace was just lasering her.  It was two bitches going after each other.  The difference?  One of them didn't feed their two year old son to fucking alligators.

HBox

09-20-2006, 06:07 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: To be honest, I've never watched Grace's show. But I didn't see the issue with her line of questioning. It's very simple - what stores did she go to? Where did she go? Melinda had a snippy attitude as well. Don't act like Melinda was sobbing on the phone and Grace was just lasering her. It was two bitches going after each other. The difference? One of them didn't feed their two year old son to fucking alligators.   The bottom line is that she didn't know shit for sure and for all she knew she could have been berating on national television a woman who had just lost her child to a kidnapping. This is how she operates, guilty unitl proven innocent. She was all over John Mark Carr and how guilty he was. It's not her fucking job to do interrogations on natrional television. That she might have stumbled into forcing a murderer to kill herself doesn't change what a cancer she is on journalism. And now we'll all probably never know for sure what happened. Perhaps a murderer got take the easy way out. Thank you Nancy Fucking Grace you maggot infested cunt.

Sheeplovr

09-20-2006, 06:09 PM

wait so whos the bad guy nowi still say its matty

mikeyboy

09-20-2006, 06:10 PM

Regardless of outcome, Nancy Grace is an awful person doing awful things in the name of journalism.  HBox is right -- she sure has hell didn't know anything for certain, and it certain;y isn't her job to insert herself into a police investigation.  If you need more proof, look at that the ambush interview she had with Elizabeth Smart.

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 06:15 PM

mikeyboy wrote: Regardless of outcome, Nancy Grace is an awful person doing awful things in the name of journalism. HBox is right -- she sure has hell didn't know anything for certain, and it certain;y isn't her job to insert herself into a police investigation. If you need more proof, look at that the ambush interview she had with Elizabeth Smart.   No one twisted Melinda's arm to go on the show.

mikeyboy

09-20-2006, 06:18 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote:  mikeyboy wrote: Regardless of outcome, Nancy Grace is an awful person doing awful things in the name of journalism. HBox is right -- she sure has hell didn't know anything for certain, and it certain;y isn't her job to insert herself into a police investigation. If you need more proof, look at that the ambush interview she had with Elizabeth Smart.    No one twisted Melinda's arm to go on the show.  ...and?  That doesn't mean a thing.  Elizabeth Smart didn't have to appear on her show either, but she was given assurances that she would be interviewed about a bill she supported and not her abduction.  I'm not justifying Melinda Duckett's decision to do appear, and I sure as hell am not defending the actions she took with her own child.  I'm talking about Nancy Grace's conduct, pure and simple.

TheMojoPin

09-20-2006, 06:42 PM

Why is nobody listening to Sheepy?

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 06:49 PM

mikeyboy wrote:...and? That doesn't mean a thing. Elizabeth Smart didn't have to appear on her show either, but she was given assurances that she would be interviewed about a bill she supported and not her abduction. I'm not justifying Melinda Duckett's decision to do appear, and I sure as hell am not defending the actions she took with her own child. I'm talking about Nancy Grace's conduct, pure and simple.   Again.  She never asked about if she killed the kid or not.  She wanted to know where Melinda was that day.  Melinda evaded the question, and Nancy smelled blood.  Melinda copped an attitude, Nancy laid into her. She wasn't grilling her like Caffey going after Jessup.  She asked her... "What stores did you go to that day?"  "I choose not to answer."  Not "I don't remember", but intentionally being evasive. If I was going on someone's show... and wanted to get my message out there about what was going on - I'd fully lay out my day so if there was witnesses - anything - that might shed some light on what happened.If Melinda said, "Yes, I was at Kohl's," maybe someone remembers seeing someone suspcious around Kohl's... that leads to a suspect.  I'm not defending Grace on a whole here, but in this situation, Duckett was being incredibly evasive.  Grace knew she was hiding something, and she called her on it.

TheMojoPin

09-20-2006, 06:52 PM

This is story is so terribly fascinating and relevant.  I love 24 hours news coverage.

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 06:56 PM

TheMojoPin wrote: This is story is so terribly fascinating and relevant. I love 24 hours news coverage.   The new hotness is the chick who got dragged to death out in Denver.

HBox

09-20-2006, 06:59 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: TheMojoPin wrote: This is story is so terribly fascinating and relevant. I love 24 hours news coverage. The new hotness is the chick who got dragged to death out in Denver.   LOOK OUT HOT CHICK'S LITTLE SISTER!!! If you don't remember where you were at 1:07 PM on September 12th and what you were wearing and how much loose change you had in your pocket, both in terms of amount of each type of coin and total monetary value, Nancy Grace is sending out the lynch mob.

mikeyboy

09-20-2006, 07:25 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote:  mikeyboy wrote: ...and? That doesn't mean a thing. Elizabeth Smart didn't have to appear on her show either, but she was given assurances that she would be interviewed about a bill she supported and not her abduction. I'm not justifying Melinda Duckett's decision to do appear, and I sure as hell am not defending the actions she took with her own child. I'm talking about Nancy Grace's conduct, pure and simple.   Again.  She never asked about if she killed the kid or not.  She wanted to know where Melinda was that day.  Melinda evaded the question, and Nancy smelled blood.  Melinda copped an attitude, Nancy laid into her. She wasn't grilling her like Caffey going after Jessup.  She asked her... "What stores did you go to that day?"  "I choose not to answer."  Not "I don't remember", but intentionally being evasive. If I was going on someone's show... and wanted to get my message out there about what was going on - I'd fully lay out my day so if there was witnesses - anything - that might shed some light on what happened.If Melinda said, "Yes, I was at Kohl's," maybe someone remembers seeing someone suspcious around Kohl's... that leads to a suspect.  I'm not defending Grace on a whole here, but in this situation, Duckett was being incredibly evasive.  Grace knew she was hiding something, and she called her on it. Well, if you listen to the interview, her initial answer as to why she wouldn't say where she was is because "she was told not to".  Bullshit or not, investigators do try to prevent certain details of crimes from being released to the public to prevent things like false confessions and faulty tips.  Given that, that's enough reason for her not to reveal certain details of the crime.  Yes, it was probably all bullshit, but that's a perfectly valid reason not to answer Pitbull Nancy's questions.  So Big Nance smells blood?  Big deal.  She's not an investigator, and the potential damage in getting it wrong can be terrible.  As HBox pointed out, look at Richard Jewell.  As I said before, though, this isn't an isolated incident.  This is the way she conducts herself.  If you feel some sort of kinship with the abrasive and unlikeable, that's your business, but you're hard pressed to defend Nanct Grace as a journalist and person.

Fallon

09-20-2006, 07:36 PM

Clean... Clean... <img width="400" height="300" border="0" src="http://images.southparkstudios.com/media/images/514/514_13.gif" />

ADF

09-20-2006, 07:43 PM

I'm confused... who's the bad guy now? I still say it's Matty.

Plethora

09-20-2006, 07:51 PM

ADF wrote: I'm confused... who's the bad guy now? I still say it's Matty.  Shit, I thought it was sheepy.  Or should I say: shit though i wa shepys z I am shocked, shocked to see that tenbats is defending Nancy Grace...       Miss giggly sheepy.

El Mudo

09-20-2006, 07:53 PM

Wait a second...  Matty killed Nancy Grace?

suggums

09-20-2006, 07:56 PM

and i helped!

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 08:03 PM

Plethora wrote: I am shocked, shocked to see that tenbats is defending Nancy Grace...    So I guess you defend a child murderer, then?

ADF

09-20-2006, 08:05 PM

Yes, that would be the logical rebuttal.

Plethora

09-20-2006, 08:09 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: Plethora wrote: I am shocked, shocked to see that tenbats is defending Nancy Grace... So I guess you defend a child murderer, then?  <Ron Voice> Like I always do... Like I always do. </Ron Voice>

Tenbatsuzen

09-20-2006, 08:09 PM

ADF wrote: Yes, that would be the logical rebuttal.    As I said, I don't watch Nancy Grace's show.  And to use Jewell as a defense in this situation is stupid.   All I know is that a two-year old kid is presumably dead, his mother did it with 99 percent certainty, and even if she didn't do it, she's a fucking worthless cunt for leaving her child (if she had nothing to do with it and he's found alive) without a mother.

HBox

09-20-2006, 08:18 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: Plethora wrote: I am shocked, shocked to see that tenbats is defending Nancy Grace... So I guess you defend a child murderer, then?   or you can just take neither side.

mikeyboy

09-20-2006, 08:22 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote:  ADF wrote: Yes, that would be the logical rebuttal.    As I said, I don't watch Nancy Grace's show.  And to use Jewell as a defense in this situation is stupid.   All I know is that a two-year old kid is presumably dead, his mother did it with 99 percent certainty, and even if she didn't do it, she's a fucking worthless cunt for leaving her child (if she had nothing to do with it and he's found alive) without a mother.  Way to ignore everyone's points, chief.  Melinda Duckett is an awful person.  Ooh, that's controversial.  Nobody's arguing with you on that, yet you use it to deflect criticism of Nancy Grace, and someone come to a warped worldview that if you somehow don't support Grace you support a child murderer.  You have to be smarter than that. And why exactly is Richard Jewell a stupid point of argument?  They were pretty damned sure he was guilty and he got torn apart in the press.  There they were wrong.  Here Nancy Grace was right.  It doesn't change the fact that at the time the accusations were made, both people were in the same boat and no one knew with any certainty who was guilty.  Again, because you seem to be ignoring the points everyone is making, Melinda Duckett is an awful person, but it doesn't justify Nancy Grace's course of action.

narc

09-20-2006, 08:37 PM

<hr color="cococo" align="left">HBox wrote: Tenbatsuzen wrote: Plethora wrote: I am shocked, shocked to see that tenbats is defending Nancy Grace... So I guess you defend a child murderer, then? or you can just take neither side. <hr color="cococo" align="left">

That's what I do. This is why I respect HBox, even though I don't agree with him on other things. If you saw Nancy Grace's show or read anything about her, you'd realize what sleaze she is. She's not a child molester or anything, but she's little better. I'd put her on the same level with O'Reilly.

Krieger

09-20-2006, 08:48 PM

Honestly why does anyone give a shit about this? Like this shit doesnt happen everyday? We should do away with this part of the media, If elected into office I promise to get rid of all tabloids, celeb rumor magazines, non serious news that doesn't effect more then a state. And I'd lock up orielly and grace. But seriously why! why ! why! do people fucking watch this garbage, its none of your fucking business. Its all middle aged nosey cunts that have nothing better to do because theyre kids are all grown up and freshly out of the house. Media sucks , end of story.

nate1000

09-21-2006, 04:52 AM

Judge Smails wrote: Maybe a Dingo ate her baby.What? Mandingo ate her baby?

Plethora

09-21-2006, 07:38 AM

nate1000 wrote: Judge Smails wrote: Maybe a Dingo ate her baby.What? Mandingo ate her baby?  What? Mandy Patinkin ate Arby's?

epo

09-21-2006, 06:27 PM

Angry Kevin wrote: Honestly why does anyone give a shit about this? Like this shit doesnt happen everyday? We should do away with this part of the media, If elected into office I promise to get rid of all tabloids, celeb rumor magazines, non serious news that doesn't effect more then a state. And I'd lock up orielly and grace. But seriously why! why ! why! do people fucking watch this garbage, its none of your fucking business. Its all middle aged nosey cunts that have nothing better to do because theyre kids are all grown up and freshly out of the house. Media sucks , end of story. I vote Angry Kevin in 08!

FezPaul

09-21-2006, 06:32 PM

Plethora wrote: nate1000 wrote: Judge Smails wrote: Maybe a Dingo ate her baby.What? Mandingo ate her baby? What? Mandy Patinkin ate Arby's? Andy's handling fleas?

This message was edited by FezPaul on 9-21-06 @ 10:34 PM

UnknownPD

09-21-2006, 06:56 PM

Sheeplovr wrote: wait so whos the bad guy nowi still say its matty You mean the guy that knows everything about everything

tele7

09-21-2006, 07:16 PM

suggums wrote: and i helped! <img height="181" src="http://www.hometownfavorites.com/images/items/Large/hfst802.jpg" width="113" border="0" />If so.  Brilliant!

SatCam

09-23-2006, 01:58 PM

Selfish, piece of shit cunt.

And what about Melinda Duckett?

JimBeam

09-23-2006, 02:16 PM

Regardless of what Grace did to them woman the woman did kill her baby.Thats why she cried. Not because Grace hurt her feelings.I dont care if it was Grace, Larry King, or anybody,The woman agreed to go on the show knowing that something had happened to her baby.How is Grace the demon in that scenario ?Oh wait I think I know why .... her politics, which dont come into play here, tend to be conservative.I have it now.

mikeyboy

09-23-2006, 02:29 PM

JimBeam wrote: Regardless of what Grace did to them woman the woman did kill her baby.Thats why she cried. Not because Grace hurt her feelings.I dont care if it was Grace, Larry King, or anybody,The woman agreed to go on the show knowing that something had happened to her baby.How is Grace the demon in that scenario ?Oh wait I think I know why .... her politics, which dont come into play here, tend to be conservative.I have it now.Bullshit.  Did you actually hear it?  There was no crying.  The woman did kill herself, but that was clearly out of guilt.  I'm not defending the woman at all.  She was an awful, awful human being who took her son's life.  The way Nancy Grace conducted herself (given that she really didn't know for sure that the woman was guilty) and the way she conducts herself on a regular basis, is totally out of bounds.  P.S. - I had no idea of Nancy Grace's political leanings, so your pat little way of tying it all up with a neat bow as a case bi-partisan bias is steaming pile of horse shit.

Tenbatsuzen

09-23-2006, 02:55 PM

mikeyboy wrote:Bullshit. Did you actually hear it? There was no crying. The woman did kill herself, but that was clearly out of guilt. I'm not defending the woman at all. She was an awful, awful human being who took her son's life. The way Nancy Grace conducted herself (given that she really didn't know for sure that the woman was guilty) and the way she conducts herself on a regular basis, is totally out of bounds. P.S. - I had no idea of Nancy Grace's political leanings, so your pat little way of tying it all up with a neat bow as a case bi-partisan bias is steaming pile of horse shit.    BTW, Mikey, the reason why this thread was started was to bring out news about what Duckett did, not debate Nancy Grace.  Because as I said, I never watched her show.  Unfortunately, people just know about the woman who killed herself on Nancy Grace, which is the only reason why I brought it up. The more details I hear about this chick (Duckett), the more I throw up a little in my mouth.

Don Stugots

09-23-2006, 03:12 PM

let me lighten the mood here a bit, you two have been knocking heads a bit so i will attempted to interject some humor here.......ok, here it goes........................ Maybe the dingo ate she baby? how did i do?  hah? hah?

mikeyboy

09-23-2006, 03:18 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote:  mikeyboy wrote: Bullshit. Did you actually hear it? There was no crying. The woman did kill herself, but that was clearly out of guilt. I'm not defending the woman at all. She was an awful, awful human being who took her son's life. The way Nancy Grace conducted herself (given that she really didn't know for sure that the woman was guilty) and the way she conducts herself on a regular basis, is totally out of bounds. P.S. - I had no idea of Nancy Grace's political leanings, so your pat little way of tying it all up with a neat bow as a case bi-partisan bias is steaming pile of horse shit. BTW, Mikey, the reason why this thread was started was to bring out news about what Duckett did, not debate Nancy Grace.  Because as I said, I never watched her show.  Unfortunately, people just know about the woman who killed herself on Nancy Grace, which is the only reason why I brought it up.The more details I hear about this chick (Duckett), the more I throw up a little in my mouth.Really?  Well, the fact that you started your thread like this:  Remember the woman who appeared on Nancy Grace and then killed herself, then Grace got crucified for "abusing" that "poor woman"?  Your choice of quotes suggests otherwise.  That and the frequent smugness that creeps into your posts suggests "Hey, you people who thought that Nancy Grace acted like a bitch -- you're wrong"I also find it curious that you claimed that your thread had nothing to do with Nancy Grace, yet chose to adopt the naive and ridiculous world-view that if you were critical of Nancy Grace, you were supporting a child murderer.  Your posts took the slant of defending Nancy Grace.  When people called you out on it, and provided specific examples of the unprofessional way she conducts herself, you hid behind ignorance rather than defending your position.Furthermore, your "intent" in starting a thread is irrelevant.  It's a discussion, and topics and ideas organically stem from the posts.  Because you claim that the thread wasn't about Nancy Grace doesn't mean that it can't be.It's retarded that I have to repeat this over and over again.  No one supports a child murderer.  However, Duckett's guilt and Grace's unprofessionalism are really mutually exclusive.  She conducted herself without knowing that Duckett was guilty and decided to act like she was an investigator.  In a sense she got lucky.  If Duckett was innocent and became despondent following the interview because of the loss of her son and the timbre of the interview and killed herself, Grace likely wouldn't be employed right now.  However, she was guilty, so it's all okay.  Score one for the awful people.  Couple her conduct here with her conduct in other instances (like the Elizabeth Smart interview), and it paints a rather bleak picture of Grace as a person and a journalist.And in case this continues to remain unclear: Nancy Grace = Bad Person.  Child Murder = Much Worse Person.

This message was edited by mikeyboy on 9-23-06 @ 7:20 PM

kellermcgee21

09-23-2006, 03:21 PM

STUGOTS1 wrote: let me lighten the mood here a bit, you two have been knocking heads a bit so i will attempted to interject some humor here.......ok, here it goes........................ Maybe the dingo ate she baby? how did i do?  hah? hah? <img height="503" src="http://www.sccs.swarthmore.edu/org/debate/propaganda/fall02_car_crash.jpg" width="488" border="0" />

Don Stugots

09-23-2006, 03:22 PM

that one was supposed to bomb.

Sheeplovr

09-23-2006, 03:31 PM

did anyone make a turduckette joke yet?put the duck in the chikcen the chicken in the turkey the turkey in the baby killer

Tenbatsuzen

09-23-2006, 03:36 PM

Sheepy wins, lock the damn thread.

kellermcgee21

09-23-2006, 03:41 PM

STUGOTS1 wrote: that one was supposed to bomb. <img src="http://www.geektimes.com/michael/site/archive/2004/11/images/mission-accomplished.jpg" border="0" />

This message was edited by kellermcgee21 on 9-23-06 @ 7:42 PM

sailor

09-23-2006, 03:55 PM

Tenbatsuzen wrote: HBox wrote: And I'm sure Nancy Grace knew all this and didn't just assume she was guilty and go for the sensationalistic angle consequences be damned. She knew she was guilty, had the evidence, and she went after a woman who had just lost her child for whatever reason out of a sense of justice, not a shameless ratings grab. What am I saying, Grace knew she was guilty and was just eviscerating this woman because she knows all at all times. She's a hero, not a perverse cunt who gets off on being judge jury and exectuioner. News organizations and journalists usually have "inside" information that's not for public consumption. For example, it was a well-known fact that McGreevey was gay before he came out with the NJ news media. I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if a police source tipped off to Grace or Grace's staff that she was the lone, primary suspect.   i'd think the operative word would be "suspect"