Where do you go for the BEST pizza?

[Hottub]

Some of you know about "Brooklyn Brick Oven" in Hackensack, but my go-to pizza spot is Nick's Pizza.
A classic pie. (pzza-off happening soon)
What do you got?

[Don Stugots]

L & B when i am in Brooklyn

Lombardi's when i want pizza in the city

Brooklyn's Bag O Pizza when I am at Tub's house.

[instrument]

I go to the shop with the mexicans posing as italians.

[lleeder]

Chicago.

[Snoogans]

Domino's

[Don Stugots]

Domino's

you really are a pot head

[Gvac]

Chicago.

Amen.

This thin crust bullshit I'm forced to eat is for chicks and homos.

And whoever invented the "bar pie" (which is basically sauce and cheese on a cracker) should have his nuts cut off.

[Snoogans]

Obviously I was also kidding

[Snoogans]

Amen.

This thin crust bullshit I'm forced to eat is for chicks and homos.

You want Chicago style pizza. Take a real NY style slice and put it on a piece of bread. SAME SHIT

[led37zep]

Artichoke in Manhattan.

[drjoek]

Moira was running @ Yale yesterday and we went to Pepe's on Wooster Street in New Haven. Simple the best.

[Hottub]

Amen.

This thin crust bullshit I'm forced to eat is for chicks and homos.

And whoever invented the "bar pie" (which is basically sauce and cheese on a cracker) should have his nuts cut off.

Kinchley's?
Lido?

For shame, G!:nono:

[disneyspy]

You want Chicago style pizza. Take a real NY style slice and put it on a piece of bread. SAME SHIT

you sound more like ffb everyday

[lleeder]

You want Chicago style pizza. Take a real NY style slice and put it on a piece of bread. SAME SHIT

Can you post that in the recipes thread.

[Snoogans]

you sound more like ffb everyday

who?

[Gvac]

Kinchley's?
Lido?

For shame, G!:nono:

I'd rather have English Muffin pizza!

[Snoogans]

Kinchley's?
Lido?

For shame, G!:nono:

Kinchley's SUCKS BALLS. Roxanne's is so much better and like 3 blocks away.


Seriously, Kinchley's is TERRIBLE

[Hottub]

Kinchley's has deep fried ravioli!

[Snoogans]

Kinchley's has deep fried ravioli!

so what? Domino's has pizza, it doesnt mean its fuckin good

[Death Metal Moe]

You want REAL, AUTHENTIC Italian cuisine? You buy it by the box my friends:

http://graphics.samsclub.com/images/products/0004111800970_LG.jpg

[Death Metal Moe]

On a more serious, edible note, best pizza I've ever had is Joey's Pizza in Milford, PA.

Sounds weird, I know. There's some Russian looking guy in the back ordering around a few Mexicans and like 3 high school girls who take your order, but it doesn't matter. It's the best pizza I've ever eaten and I've had quite a bit of pizza in my time.

The crust is always thin and delicious, just the right amout of sauce and they seem to use good quality cheese that is never too greasy. Place makes a decent salad and other normal pizza place stuff like bread sticks and garlic knots.

If you ever find yourself in the middle of nowhere, be sure to try it out.

[Don Stugots]

On a more serious, edible note, best pizza I've ever had is Joey's Pizza in Milford, PA.

Sounds weird, I know. There's some Russian looking guy in the back ordering around a few Mexicans and like 3 high school girls who take your order, but it doesn't matter. It's the best pizza I've ever eaten and I've had quite a bit of pizza in my time.

The crust is always thin and delicious, just the right amout of sauce and they seem to use good quality cheese that is never too greasy. Place makes a decent salad and other normal pizza place stuff like bread sticks and garlic knots.

If you ever find yourself in the middle of nowhere, be sure to try it out.

Joeys? you are nuts, they are ARABS, they do not know how to make pizza and the proof is when i tasted their pizza, i spit it out and told them thanks for failing. House of Pizza in Milford was good until the owner died of old age.

[Snoogans]

ive never once eaten a slice of pizza outside the state limits of NY or NJ

[disneyspy]

ive never once eaten a slice of pizza outside the state limits of NY or NJ

you poor guy,thats horrible,im sorry

[Snoogans]

you poor guy,thats horrible,im sorry

actually I have a feeling I should be happy about it

[instrument]

Ellios pizza gave me the shits.

[Death Metal Moe]

Joeys? you are nuts, they are ARABS, they do not know how to make pizza and the proof is when i tasted their pizza, i spit it out and told them thanks for failing. House of Pizza in Milford was good until the owner died of old age.

Tried all the pizza joints out there a few times, Joey's hands down. All the others are pretenders to the throne of PA Pizza places.

Deal with it homes.

[Death Metal Moe]

Ellios pizza gave me the shits.

Of course it did, didn't you read the fine print on the box down by the UPC code before you bought it?

[EliSnow]

actually I have a feeling I should be happy about it


Naw, New Haven Ct has fantastic pizza and I've had the best of NYC.

[Chip196]

Grimaldi's in DUMBO is my favorite.

[Snoogans]

Naw, New Haven Ct has fantastic pizza and I've had the best of NYC.

When I'm going through CT my goal is to get through it into a real place as fast as possible. No stopping for pizza, especially in a shit hole like New Haven

[Hottub]

When I'm going through CT my goal is to get through it into a real place as fast as possible. No stopping for pizza, especially in a shit hole like New Haven

A.J. should kick your ass.

[booster11373]

Martio's pizza Nanuet New York its what I dream of

[underdog]

When I'm going through CT my goal is to get through it into a real place as fast as possible. No stopping for pizza, especially in a shit hole like New Haven

A.J. should kick your ass.

I don't think anyone would argue that New Haven is a shit hole.

[drjoek]

When I'm going through CT my goal is to get through it into a real place as fast as possible. No stopping for pizza, especially in a shit hole like New Haven



You realize you're from Mahwah NJ don't you ?

[lleeder]

I don't think anyone would argue that New Haven is a shit hole.

Pistol wavin

[Don Stugots]

I don't think anyone would argue that New Haven is a shit hole.

there are a few good bars there from what i remember.

[MHasegawa]

Neil's in Clifton

Angelo's in Clifton

[Heather 8]

As of Friday night, Irene's in Spring Lake. Danny from Spumoni Gardens is a godsend.

[Jughead]

Brunos Been in business here since 1960....

[MC Pee Pants]

Caffaro's here in South River NJ for a regular slice, Brother's in East Brunswick for a great vodka slice.

[Knowledged_one]

In troy or when i was in indy it was papa murphys

[BeerBandit]

Some of you know about "Brooklyn Brick Oven" in Hackensack, but my go-to pizza spot is Nick's Pizza.
A classic pie. (pzza-off happening soon)
What do you got?
Brooklyn Brick Oven is really good but a little on the expensive side. Took a lunch over there a few months ago. Goddamn there's baaaaaaad pizza in Teterboro.
Moira was running @ Yale yesterday and we went to Pepe's on Wooster Street in New Haven. Simple the best.
Apizza was one of the best parts of going to school in New Haven. That and Toad's Place. But I prefer Modern Apizza. So, so good!
On a more serious, edible note, best pizza I've ever had is Joey's Pizza in Milford, PA.


Joey's always seemed undercooked. The cheese was too chewy, the crust not crispy enough. The best in the area for my bet was across the river in my hometown of Montague, NJ. Candy's pizza. Delicious crispy crust, good sauce and perfect cheese. Piuki swears by their calzones.

Here in Middletown, NY I'll tell anybody that'll listen, Badabing's is tops. Not perfect, though. There is one day when the old guy is making the dough that it's less than stellar, but I highly recommend this place. Just don't forget to let me know if you going, we'll split a pie.

[Death Metal Moe]

I can't believe all this Joey's shit talkin'! DIZZAM!

[King Hippos Bandaid]

wow so many awful places on here

Artichoke is awsome in the city

L&Bs is my favorite place to get a square slice, but by a 1/2 sheet , not a slice, the slices WAY too small

SI the best is Deninos

NJ , the shore (seaside etc) is good, regular Jersey Pizza is generic at best

as for PA, Im sorry, but I would never attempt to buy Pizza there

[west milly Tom]

Kinchley's has deep fried ravioli!

Had some last night after the party. Sweet!

[spot]

Moira was running @ Yale yesterday and we went to Pepe's on Wooster Street in New Haven. Simple the best.
They opened a Pepe's in Fairfield that's almost as good, Doc.

[Marc with a c]

Grimaldi's in DUMBO is my favorite.

i don't think i have ever had pizza so fresh and yummy.

[Chip196]

i don't think i have ever had pizza so fresh and yummy.

It really is amazing IMO.

In Northern Westchester, Portofinos in Goldens Bridge is the best in the area.

[spot]

And they have gigantic slices! Good stuff Portofinos..

[Don Stugots]

Grimaldi's in DUMBO is my favorite.

its down town Brooklyn you hipster prick

[Marc with a c]

its down town Brooklyn you hipster prick

i always considered it dumbo.

[Enabler]

Joeys? when i tasted their pizza, i spit it out and told them thanks for failing.

Classy.:tongue:

When I used to live in Westwood Id always get Cousins Pizza in Rivervale, but Im sure they're under new mgmt and probably suck by now. Now I mostly order from Prestos in West New York. Its brick oven and they have some good specialty pizzas. The Prestos in Hackensack isnt nearly as good for some reason.

[joethebartender]

Some of you know about "Brooklyn Brick Oven" in Hackensack, but my go-to pizza spot is Nick's Pizza.
A classic pie. (pzza-off happening soon)
What do you got?

I agree Tub, Nick's has a good pie. I call there for delivery. (I'm impressed, I didn't think you were fat enough to know the way of the dough.)

A new favorite of mine is in Montclair, NJ called Leone's.

[Kublakhan61]

its down town Brooklyn you hipster prick

HAHAHA!
I'm a firm believer in Di Fara Pizza in Midwood. I know Fred slagged them off on-air but it can't be beat.
In NYC I go to Patsy's on University, but really why eat pizza in NYC - it's rubbish for the most part. (I haven't tried Artichoke yet but I'm weary of them on account of their hype).
I need to give L&B another try. I was very underwhelmed after hearing so much about it on R&F.

[Chip196]

its down town Brooklyn you hipster prick

Ok .. sorry .. .it's Downtown Brooklyn, you know Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass.

i always considered it dumbo.

THHAAANNKK YOUUU!

[Don Stugots]

Ok .. sorry .. .it's Downtown Brooklyn, you know Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass.



THHAAANNKK YOUUU!


:tongue: but its under the brooklyn bridge.

[Chip196]

And they have gigantic slices! Good stuff Portofinos..

yeah ... you'd have to work real hard to finish 2 slices.

and the rest of their food is stellar as well.

[Chip196]

:tongue: but its under the brooklyn bridge.

Ha ... yes sir, you're right. But they're so close together, one could only assume DUMBO was more than a 5 square block area. Eisther way ... best Pizza I've ever had

[Don Stugots]

Ha ... yes sir, you're right. But they're so close together, one could only assume DUMBO was more than a 5 square block area. Eisther way ... best Pizza I've ever had

true, it is very good pizza.

[BrooklynKat]

true, it is very good pizza.

I think Grimaldi's is fa-bu-lous!
L&B is reliable for a "dirty" slice.

[tele7]

There's just no decent pizza in central NJ. The only place that comes close is Ferraras on Amboy Ave in Edison. There's another one on Inman ave that's just as good.

The best pizza I've had was at the Anchor Inn in Bayville. Just a bar pie, but it was awesome. Thin crust w/ extra sauce.

[mdr55]

Larry and Joe's Pizzaria in Jersey City

[FezsAssistant]

i always considered it dumbo.

it's certainly not downtown.

[FezsAssistant]

I still haven't had pizza as good as what I had growing up in Niagara Falls, NY. Huge Italian population and lots of places to get great pizza.
I've lived in NYC for 8.5 years and NYC pizza is shit. You generally can't find a decent slice.
I'd say the exception is Grimaldi's. I hear there are some other good brick oven places, too, which I still have to get to.

[Coach]

Caffaro's here in South River NJ for a regular slice, Brother's in East Brunswick for a great vodka slice.Used to get Chicken Parms and Pie from Coffaro's in East Brunswick at Rutgers..great!
Scranton....Nicholas' Pizza ...thin crust... fucking amazing! Old Forge Pa. Claims to be the "Pizza Capital of the USA"...Basically midcrust Sicilian pie but shitty contents and cheese.

[Hottub]

[QUOTE=joethebartender;2075284]I agree Tub, Nick's has a good pie. I call there for delivery. (I'm impressed, I didn't think you were fat enough to know the way of the dough.)

QUOTE]

Tell that to my Doctor.:annoyed:

[RogerPodacter]

i live in southern california, so there IS NO good pizza here. i'd rather shove shit in my mouth...oh wait.

[Enabler]

i live in southern california, so there IS NO good pizza here. i'd rather shove shit in my mouth...oh wait.


Oddly enough, California Pizza Kitchen is probably my favorite frozen pizza.

[Don Stugots]

I'm going to LA in a few weeks, where can I get som good pizza?

[Hottub]

I'm going to LA in a few weeks, where can I get som good pizza?

Better pack a pie to go.

[Recyclerz]

If we're talking best, my vote goes to Patsy's up on 1st Ave in Harlem.

Two Boots is very good as is Totonno's in Coney island if you're out that way. (Totonno's opened a place in Yonkers less than 2 miles from my house but it was relly disappointing compared to the Coney Island version.) I'm taking notes from this thread and will judge you as a person based on your suggestions herein, as I sample my way towards a heart attack.

[DrexlSpivey]

totonnos.. prob the best.. better than grimaldis or lombardis.. difara is real cheesy and greasy... l &b has become ellios

[RogerPodacter]

Better pack a pie to go.

yeah, in fact would ya mind bringing me a pie as well?

[ANC]

There's just no decent pizza in central NJ.

QFT, although the Brothers Pizza on Route 18 (orig. location on Staten Island) is pretty good.

For the best pizza, I go to Denino's on Port Richmond Avenue in Staten Island.

[weekapaugjz]

This thread has me craving pizza for lunch.