Top 10 QB's of all time

[TripleSkeet]

Since this is a discussion going on in the NFL thread, I figured Id put the question out there and see what the results are. I think we will see just how subjective the answers to this can be....

My Top 10

1. Joe Montana - 4 Super Bowl rings (1 before Jerry Rice came along), he revolutionized the passing game in the NFL. The west coast offense he ran is pretty much what most NFL teams try to recapture every year. 11 TD's, 0 Ints, and a 127 QB rating in the Super Bowl. Ridiculous.

2. Tom Brady - 3 Super Bowl rings throwing to receivers that are now washing cars somewhere. 1 fluke catch away from going 19-0, taking his 4th Super Bowl, and Joe Cools number 1 spot on this list.

3. John Elway - 2 Super Bowl rings, 3 more trips to the big game. Maybe the most clutch 2 minute QB of all time. Maybe.

4. Peyton Manning - 1 Super Bowl ring, with a 2nd perhaps in 2 weeks. Crazy stats and records. Strong challenger to Elway for that most clutch 2 minute QB of all time.

5. Johnny Unitas - 1 Super Bowl ring, 2 NFL Championship rings, The pioneer of the modern QB.

6. Brett Favre - 1 Super Bowl ring. Still bringing his teams to the conference championship game at 40 years old.

7. Steve Young - 1 Super Bowl ring, took over for a legend and actually filled his shoes. If it werent for those loaded Dallas teams he would definitely have at least 1 or 2 more rings.

8. Dan Marino - 0 Super Bowl rings, but owned the record book before Peyton Manning and Tom Brady came along.

9. Troy Aikman - 3 Super Bowl rings, tough clutch player. Prototypical QB.

10. Terry Bradshaw - 4 Super Bowl Rings. Which alone makes him belong on this list. Undervalued because he played on a team with a great running game and world class defense.

Honorable mention*
Fran Tarkenton, Dan Fouts, Warren Moon, Jim Kelly, Phil Simms, Bart Starr.

[hammersavage]

Manning is above Brady if he wins in 2 weeks. That is all

[TripleSkeet]

Manning is above Brady if he wins in 2 weeks. That is all

Sorry. But no. But I will put him above Elway.

[Dan 'Hampton]

Because 2 is more than 3. Makes sense.

[hammersavage]

yup

[Don Stugots]

no love for Ken O'Brien?

[Dan 'Hampton]

Plus the busted thumb has had hall of fame wr's his whole career. Brady-1.

[Dan 'Hampton]

Tony Eason? Played in Superbowl.

[goreds2]

Ben Roethlisberger will be in the Top 10 before his career is over. (2 rings and hopefully more)

[epo]

Brett Favre should NEVER be above Bart Starr on any list.

Ever.

Never.

Ever.

[instrument]

is this of all time or your lifetime?

[disneyspy]

a list with no roger staubach is a stupid list

[midwestjeff]

http://a.espncdn.com/i/mag/blog/JimmyMacMac.jpg

[TripleSkeet]

a list with no roger staubach is a stupid list

It was a toss up between him and Aikman. Aikman got the nod because of the extra ring. Im a Philly fan, youre lucky I was able to put one on there.

Im interested in seeing how you guys rank them.

[TripleSkeet]

is this of all time or your lifetime?

All time. Its not my fault in the 60's and 70's most teams only wanted to run. I just cant put guys like Len Dawson and Joe Namath up there with Elway and Montana.

Although I do have a weak spot for Slingin Sammy Baugh.

[disneyspy]

It was a toss up between him and Aikman. Aikman got the nod because of the extra ring. Im a Philly fan, youre lucky I was able to put one on there.

Im interested in seeing how you guys rank them.

10 bobby lane
9 jim kelly
8 randal cunningham
7 joe montana
6 dan marino
5 tom brady
4 peyton manning
3 john elway
2 troy aikman
1 roger staubach

[TripleSkeet]

10 bobby lane
9 jim kelly
8 randal cunningham
7 joe montana
6 dan marino
5 tom brady
4 peyton manning
3 john elway
2 troy aikman
1 roger staubach

At least youre not a homer.

[disneyspy]

At least youre not a homer.

i dont know,i'm gettin pretty tired of women and their bullshit

[Hottub]

http://i.cdn.turner.com/si/multimedia/photo_gallery/0903/nfl.10.afl.franchises/images/jack-kemp-buffalo-bills.jpg

[Al Davis]

1. JaMarcus Russell

Yeah, that's the whole fucking list. He's a special player, get over it. Best fucking QB of all time. And if you don't agree, you can go fuck yourself.

Where the fuck is Shell? I need changed again. Tell him to get the extra strength Depends this time.

[razorboy]

http://i29.photobucket.com/albums/c297/razorboy_/romangabrielpf-1.jpg

Fine. Maybe not in the top ten, but redefined the position in the modern era and he still belongs in the hall.

[Ritalin]

http://a.espncdn.com/i/mag/blog/JimmyMacMac.jpg

He's definitely the punkiest.

[razorboy]

He's definitely the punkiest.

Well he can't dance, but he can throw the pill.

[goreds2]

http://a.espncdn.com/i/mag/blog/JimmyMacMac.jpg

The coolest? YES!

Also, I think Fran Tarkenton deserves some honorable mention.

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/T/TarkFr00.htm

[TripleSkeet]

The coolest? YES!

Also, I think Fran Tarkenton deserves some honorable mention.

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/T/TarkFr00.htm

You mustve missed this part...

Honorable mention*
Fran Tarkenton, Dan Fouts, Warren Moon, Jim Kelly, Phil Simms, Bart Starr.

[King Hippos Bandaid]

Manning is above Brady if he wins in 2 weeks. That is all


lock it up


this is the right answer

brady right place right time



I would say Manning > Montana if he

wins 2 more superbowls
wins 1 more superbowl and makes it to 1 more


Brady is a paper chump... You are blinded by the 3 Rings, he is a great QB , but top 3 of all time you've got to be kidding me

[jauble]

lock it up


this is the right answer

brady right place right time



I would say Manning > Montana if he

wins 2 more superbowls
wins 1 more superbowl and makes it to 1 more


Brady is a paper chump... You are blinded by the 3 Rings, he is a great QB , but top 3 of all time you've got to be kidding me

Whats your tops overall?

[King Hippos Bandaid]

Whats your tops overall?

Montana
Manning
Unitas

[DolaMight]

enough with best, bottom 10 starts now:

leading the defeat, J.P. Lossman

could you have a worse NFL surname?

[weekapaugjz]

enough with best, bottom 10 starts now:

leading the defeat, J.P. Lossman

could you have a worse NFL surname?

rob johnson was actually much worse.

[disneyspy]

rob johnson was actually much worse.

tavaris jackson,jack son

[DolaMight]

rob johnson was actually much worse.

true, but one bowl of flutie flakes woulda made rob a pocket 6' champ. too bad.

[King Hippos Bandaid]

enough with best, bottom 10 starts now:

leading the defeat, J.P. Lossman

could you have a worse NFL surname?

here are some terrible Qbs

Browning Nagle
Bobby Hoying
Stan Gelbough
Billy Jo Tolliver
Rick Mirer
Glen Foley
Dave Brown
David Klinger
Tim Couch
Andre Ware

[weekapaugjz]

here are some terrible Qbs

Browning Nagle
Bobby Hoying
Stan Gelbough
Billy Jo Tolliver
Rick Mirer
Glen Foley
Dave Brown
David Klinger
Tim Couch
Andre Ware

ryan leaf

[DolaMight]

here are some terrible Qbs

Browning Nagle
Bobby Hoying
Stan Gelbough
Billy Jo Tolliver
Rick Mirer
Glen Foley
Dave Brown
David Klinger
Tim Couch
Andre Ware

ouch, I got an orange tim couch jersey, take it back. I feel like a million TB bucks in it.

[Snoogans]

Charlie Ward
Charlie Ward
Charlie Ward
Charlie Ward
Charlie Ward
Tommy Frazier
Tommy Frazier
Tommy Frazier
Tommy Frazier
Kenny O'Brien

[King Hippos Bandaid]

ryan leaf

ofcourse, he is obvious I like bringing it old school with less familiar rejects

Heath Schuler

in 10 yrs we will be sayng Jarmarcus Russell, he will be the new Ryan Leaf 2K edition

[KnoxHarrington]

enough with best, bottom 10 starts now:

leading the defeat, J.P. Lossman

could you have a worse NFL surname?

I loved for a while they tried to get people to say it "LOHS-man", but soon it was back to "LOSS-man".

[King Hippos Bandaid]

we could say any Jet QB from 1982-1996 (minus boomer)

[weekapaugjz]

in 10 yrs we will be sayng Jarmarcus Russell, he will be the new Ryan Leaf 2K edition

i'd like to hear al davis's take on this.

[jauble]

ryan leaf

I remember when assholes booed in Indy because the Colts selected Manning.

[barjockey]

A list that doesnt include Shane Falco or Johnny Utah is just bogus dude!!

[KnoxHarrington]

Throw Akili Smith on that list too. What a bust.

[Snoogans]

A list that doesnt include Shane Falco or Johnny Utah is just bogus dude!!

I dont know man. I mighta had Falco in until that disastrous Sugar Bowl

[barjockey]

I dont know man. I mighta had Falco in until that disastrous Sugar Bowl

Hey Shane Falco. I lost a ton of money on that Sugar Bowl disaster of yours. What a bloody shambles that was. You could smell the stink all the way back in bloody Wales.

[epo]

If Johnny Utah hadn't had that bum knee of his....

[Snoogans]

why cant the giants get burress out on work release like Gene Hackman did?

[epo]

Who would a judge listen to, Gene Hackman or Tom Coughlin?

Come on!

[Snoogans]

Who would a judge listen to, Gene Hackman or Tom Coughlin?

Come on!

please, if a judge is gonna listen to Jimmy McNulty, then Tom Coughlin should be able to get something done

[epo]

please, if a judge is gonna listen to Jimmy McNulty, then Tom Coughlin should be able to get something done

Coughlin couldn't convince that pansy Tiki to suit up.

[Snoogans]

Coughlin couldn't convince that pansy Tiki to suit up.

good. fuck that ringless bastard

[epo]

Tom Coughlin might be the only way to convince Brett Favre to retire.

[TripleSkeet]

lock it up


this is the right answer

brady right place right time



I would say Manning > Montana if he

wins 2 more superbowls
wins 1 more superbowl and makes it to 1 more


Brady is a paper chump... You are blinded by the 3 Rings, he is a great QB , but top 3 of all time you've got to be kidding me

Much like your football picks you couldnt be more ridiculously wrong.

Right place right time? To win 3 fucking Super Bowls? Since when is coming in when your team is 0-2 and the starting QB just got knocked out of the game the "right time". Oh, and what did he do? Thats right, went 11-3 and took his team to the Super Bowl and then beat a team that was the 2nd highest favored Super Bowl team of all time behind the fucking 1968 Colts. Youre right, he just lucked his way into that spot. Thats fucking retarded. You make him sound like Trent Dilfer.

And Manning over Joe Cool if he wins 1 more Super Bowl and loses in another??!? Are you fucking crazy? Manning never tops Montana until he has 4 RINGS. I dont care if he throws for a fucking million yards. 4 rings, or the most he gets is number 2. The man had a 127 passer rating overall and 0 interceptions in 4 fucking Super Bowls. Going against the best in the AFC in the most intense game there is. Show some fucking respect.

[Slumbag]

Much like your football picks you couldnt be more ridiculously wrong.

Right place right time? To win 3 fucking Super Bowls? Since when is coming in when your team is 0-2 and the starting QB just got knocked out of the game the "right time". Oh, and what did he do? Thats right, went 11-3 and took his team to the Super Bowl and then beat a team that was the 2nd highest favored Super Bowl team of all time behind the fucking 1968 Colts. Youre right, he just lucked his way into that spot. Thats fucking retarded. You make him sound like Trent Dilfer.

And Manning over Joe Cool if he wins 1 more Super Bowl and loses in another??!? Are you fucking crazy? Manning never tops Montana until he has 4 RINGS. I dont care if he throws for a fucking million yards. 4 rings, or the most he gets is number 2. The man had a 127 passer rating overall and 0 interceptions in 4 fucking Super Bowls. Going against the best in the AFC in the most intense game there is. Show some fucking respect.

I live in Indy, so I can't really make an unbiased decision.
I think you just don't like the Colts (Well, I don't think. You've stated it constantly). Are you just adding up SB rings and not taking anything else into consideration? If you wanna play count the shiny jewelry, than people will probably change some of there answers.

I'll disagree that Brady is just lucky. The guy was a monster QB and did countless things for the Pats. I'd put Brady ahead as far as teams go, but I'd give it to Manning for indiviual efforts. He's got 4 MVP's to Brady's 1, and has more TD's, wins, and yards.

I'd still say Joe Montana just cause no one thought he was gonna be shit. Peyton was brought in as a superstar, and Montana came in as a nobody and killed it (you do have to factor in that Manning still has a few more years).



You also probably shouldn't get so angry. It's a game. Kids play it.

[sailor]

ofcourse, he is obvious I like bringing it old school with less familiar rejects

Heath Schuler

in 10 yrs we will be sayng Jarmarcus Russell, he will be the new Ryan Leaf 2K edition

http://media.lunch.com/d/d7/137646.jpg

[A.J.]

http://webzoom.freewebs.com/jdworley/01%20Quantum%20Leaf/01%20Cent%20Season/CS-05%20Sammy%20Baugh.jpg

[El Mudo]

http://webzoom.freewebs.com/jdworley/01%20Quantum%20Leaf/01%20Cent%20Season/CS-05%20Sammy%20Baugh.jpg

Sammy Baugh was so great that he actually led the league in passing, punting AND interceptions all in the same year.

Its so difficult to compare football players because there is so much constant change in the game, unlike baseball, which is essentially the same game it has always been, even back to the 20s. I agree with Hippo's list

Montana
Manning
Unitas

Except I would put it as

Manning
Unitas
Montana

I just can't think of anyone who has played the "position" better that PM has. With Montana, you could make the argument (and some might consider it to be unfair) that he is/was a product of the most revolutionary offensive system of the last 30 years, much like people make the argument that Marty Brodeur only puts up the numbers he does because of the system played by the Devils.

With Unitas, the game was just so different in the 60s that its just impossible to compare to anything nowadays, and I have no frame of reference in terms of actually watching him play.

[King Hippos Bandaid]

Much like your football picks you couldnt be more ridiculously wrong.

Right place right time? To win 3 fucking Super Bowls? Since when is coming in when your team is 0-2 and the starting QB just got knocked out of the game the "right time". Oh, and what did he do? Thats right, went 11-3 and took his team to the Super Bowl and then beat a team that was the 2nd highest favored Super Bowl team of all time behind the fucking 1968 Colts. Youre right, he just lucked his way into that spot. Thats fucking retarded. You make him sound like Trent Dilfer.

And Manning over Joe Cool if he wins 1 more Super Bowl and loses in another??!? Are you fucking crazy? Manning never tops Montana until he has 4 RINGS. I dont care if he throws for a fucking million yards. 4 rings, or the most he gets is number 2. The man had a 127 passer rating overall and 0 interceptions in 4 fucking Super Bowls. Going against the best in the AFC in the most intense game there is. Show some fucking respect.


guess u have kissed the rings


Brady is a Great QB, just not elite, had some great seasons,the team won the superbowl, not Brady,

Manning's team has not been as successful, but as far as QBs go, Manniing is a MUCH Better QB


Mudo

Manning's story hasnt ended, I think he may surpass Montana and to be honest, I dont know the stats offhand for Unitas, but he is what all modern QBs strive to be , I am alil Biased since I grew up with Montana

[PhishHead]

How can none of you mention Otto Graham??

I would go as top 3

Montana
Unitas
Graham

[Snoogans]

How can none of you mention Otto Graham??

I would go as top 3

Montana
Unitas
Graham


http://fromtheleft.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/michael-vick-r_0.jpg

[El Mudo]

guess u have kissed the rings


Brady is a Great QB, just not elite, had some great seasons,the team won the superbowl, not Brady,

Manning's team has not been as successful, but as far as QBs go, Manniing is a MUCH Better QB


Mudo

Manning's story hasnt ended, I think he may surpass Montana and to be honest, I dont know the stats offhand for Unitas, but he is what all modern QBs strive to be , I am alil Biased since I grew up with Montana

The scary thing about Manning is that he's only 33 (doesn't turn 34 till March), and he's thrown for over 50,000 yards and 366 TDs already. That means he's averaging basically 4500 yards a season, and 33 TDs a year.

If he plays another 7 years, and his averages hold up for the most part (which they most likely will since he's never had a significant injury, nor really taken too much of a pounding), that means he'll end up with something in the neighborhood of career numbers of close to 81,000 career yards, and well over 500 TDs (Brett Favre, by comparison, has thrown for a little over 69,000 yards in his career and 497 TDs, and he hasn't missed a game in a 17 years). Those numbers are nuts.

When you throw in the fact that he's also pretty much also the offensive coordinator, its just absurd.

[TripleSkeet]

I live in Indy, so I can't really make an unbiased decision.
I think you just don't like the Colts (Well, I don't think. You've stated it constantly). Are you just adding up SB rings and not taking anything else into consideration? If you wanna play count the shiny jewelry, than people will probably change some of there answers.

I'll disagree that Brady is just lucky. The guy was a monster QB and did countless things for the Pats. I'd put Brady ahead as far as teams go, but I'd give it to Manning for indiviual efforts. He's got 4 MVP's to Brady's 1, and has more TD's, wins, and yards.

I'd still say Joe Montana just cause no one thought he was gonna be shit. Peyton was brought in as a superstar, and Montana came in as a nobody and killed it (you do have to factor in that Manning still has a few more years).



You also probably shouldn't get so angry. It's a game. Kids play it.

No I dont just count the rings, because if you look at my list there are guys on there with More rings (Aikman, Bradshaw) but are further down my list and Dan Marino is on there with no rings. But in my opinion its a VERY important part of a great QB.

A quarterbacks job is not just to pass the ball. Its to lead his team to victory. And the Super Bowl is the greatest measuring stick of that. Stats to me just arent as important because in football they are so easy to pad. Look how many late game garbage touchdown drives you see that mean nothing because the game is out of hand already? A perfect example of this is the year Manning broke Marinos record. Dont get me wrong, its still impressive, but the fact is he set the record for 1 yard touchdown passes in a season. That was because the Colts wanted him to get that record. Most coaches would just punch it in when they are on the 1. But he gets credit for all those lobs into the end zone.

And what makes me hate the Colts is people like Hippo that just start saying stuff like Peyton Mannings the greaest QB ever. Really? If he loses to the Saints he will have 1 Super Bowl ring for all those stats. Compared to a guy that won 4 and performed brilliantly in each one. Not rode his team in like someone like Trent Dilfer.

I put Peyton Manning as 4 on my list and said if he wins this year Id move him to 3. To me thats a realistic spot and fair. How can I not give the guy credit yet rank him that high all time? Not to mention if the team wouldve played for the undefeated season, and this game would be their last piece, I would be rooting for them right now. Just because Im a fan of history and like seeing history being made.

[TripleSkeet]

When you throw in the fact that he's also pretty much also the offensive coordinator, its just absurd.

Actually it makes more sense. Alot easier to have better stats when you can call whatever play you want. And thats something that doesnt really impress me because until the mid-90's thats basically what most QB's did. It wasnt until then that coaches decided their plays were written in stone and QB's werent smart enough to change them or call their own plays.

[spoon]

Oh this is easy...

Sanchez

[Snoogans]

Oh this is easy...

Sanchez

he is already the best jets QB ever

[El Mudo]

Actually it makes more sense. Alot easier to have better stats when you can call whatever play you want. And thats something that doesnt really impress me because until the mid-90's thats basically what most QB's did. It wasnt until then that coaches decided their plays were written in stone and QB's werent smart enough to change them or call their own plays.


But that also has to do with how complex offenses and defenses are nowadays. When Unitas was calling his own plays, there was nothing like Cover 2, or zone blitz schemes, 4 or 5 wide sets, or hell...even THREE wide sets. Most QB's don't call their own plays now not because they aren't smart enough, but rather, because its so much to take in and process in terms of game planning, video, and schematically week after week; its practically impossible. The fact that Manning can manage all that, and STILL be as successful as he is boggles my mind.

Even in Montana's day, offenses weren't NEARLY as complex as they are now. And in 5 years, everything will have completely changed again because of the continuing evolution of offenses and defenses. Part of what is so frustrating in a way about football is the fact that it changes so goddamn much, you can't compare anything over different eras and trends, and the time period between eras and trends keeps getting shorter and shorter because everything gets discussed, dissected and analyzed quicker and quicker.

[Snoogans]

Warren Moon

[El Mudo]

Jeff George

http://brotherpeacemaker.files.wordpress.com/2007/04/jason-whitlock.jpg

[DanMarino]

what about me?




The laces were out

[Billy "White Shoes"]

http://i568.photobucket.com/albums/ss123/texansfanblog/Old%20Player%20Pics/danpastorini.jpg

[EliManning]

umm, gee, you know, ummm, fellas. I did win super bowl MVP....

[Neckbeard]

hey Eli

[TripleSkeet]

what about me?




The laces were out

Loved that movie. So hilarious to think a coach would ever put Dan Marinos hands in harms way by holding for field goals. I dated a girl that babysitted for him and he wouldnt even pull the cord on a motorboat he was so protective of his mitts.

[El Mudo]

Loved that movie. So hilarious to think a coach would ever put Dan Marinos hands in harms way by holding for field goals. I dated a girl that babysitted for him and he wouldnt even pull the cord on a motorboat he was so protective of his mitts.

My father-in-law grew up in the same neighborhood as Marino but was a little older. When little Danny wanted to come play football with them one day, him and his friends told him to buzz off. Oof.

I could be swimming in some of that sweet Marino money right now *sigh*

[Snoogans]

Loved that movie. So hilarious to think a coach would ever put Dan Marinos hands in harms way by holding for field goals. I dated a girl that babysitted for him and he wouldnt even pull the cord on a motorboat he was so protective of his mitts.

everything will be ok as long as he has Isotoner gloves

[TripleSkeet]

everything will be ok as long as he has Isotoner gloves

Always thought those were great too. Have a guy do ads for gloves when he lives in a city thats usually 75 degrees in January.

[Snoogans]

Always thought those were great too. Have a guy do ads for gloves when he lives in a city thats usually 75 degrees in January.

if anyone knows about hands, its dan marino


plus they had those grippy things on the palm, who doesnt love that?

[Ogre]

I asked the magic Google 8 Ball and it came up with this Jambroni.
I did not realize He sucked that badly statistically. (http://www.pro-football-reference.com/blog/?p=138)

http://www.uhnd.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/8001215-chiefs-v-seahawks-242x300.jpg

The Worst QB of ALL TIME (http://www.pro-football-reference.com/blog/?p=138)

My Top 10

1 Joe Montana- body of work says it all
2 Johnny Unitas- Modern day QB before his time
3 Peyton Manning- Will break many if not all the records before it is over
4 John Elway- 5 Super Bowls with back 2 back wins riding into the sunset
5 Brett Favre- Is 2 NFC Championship game INTs in OT away from being #1 of all time
6 Tom Brady- 3 Rings and 4 trips and a monster season for the ages
7 Troy Aikman- 3 Rings. Class
8 Dan Marino- Best to never win nothing
9 Otto Graham- Won Championships almost every time
10 Steve Young- What might have been if Montana moved over sooner

[Snoogans]

i got exclusive copy of the top ten according to the avg WFAN caller:

Phil Simms
Joe Namath
Eli Manning
Mark Sanchez
Y A Tittle
Jeff Hostetler
Boomer Esiason
Dave brown
Kent Graham
Ken OBrien

[TripleSkeet]

i got exclusive copy of the top ten according to the avg WFAN caller:

Phil Simms
Joe Namath
Eli Manning
Mark Sanchez
Y A Tittle
Jeff Hostetler
Boomer Esiason
Dave brown
Kent Graham
Ken OBrien

That one kinda reminds me of Disneyspys. His was:

1. Roger Staubach
2. Troy Aikman
3. Don Meredith
4. Tomy Romo
5. Roger Staubach
6. Danny White
7. Randall Cunningham
8. Drew Bledsoe
9. Quincy Carter
10. Roger Staubach

[disneyspy]

That one kinda reminds me of Disneyspys. His was:

1. Roger Staubach
2. Troy Aikman
3. Don Meredith
4. Tomy Romo
5. Roger Staubach
6. Danny White
7. Randall Cunningham
8. Drew Bledsoe
9. Quincy Carter
10. Roger Staubach

romo is ahead of meredith

[epo]

1. Bart Starr
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Lynn Dickey
4. Don Majkowski
5. Kurt Warner
6. Mark Brunell
7. Ty Detmer
8. Matt Hasselbeck
9. Randy Wright
10. Brent Favre

[weekapaugjz]

That one kinda reminds me of Disneyspys. His was:

1. Roger Staubach
2. Troy Aikman
3. Don Meredith
4. Tomy Romo
5. Roger Staubach
6. Danny White
7. Randall Cunningham
8. Drew Bledsoe
9. Quincy Carter
10. Roger Staubach

my list goes as such:

1. jim kelly
2. jim kelly
3. jim kelly
4. jim kelly
5. jim kelly
6. jim kelly
7. jim kelly
8. jim kelly
9. jim kelly
10. frank reich

[Freakshow]

1. Vinny Testaverde
2. Kerry Collins
3. Dave Krieg
4. Jim Everett
5. Brad Johnson
6. Drew Bledsoe
7. Mark Brunell
8. Steve DeBerg
9. John Brodie
10. Norm Snead

[TripleSkeet]

1. Randall Cunningham
2. Donovan McNabb
3. Ron Jaworski
4. Norm Van Brocklin
5. Sonny Jurgenson
6. Roman Gabriel
7. Jim McMahon
8. Jeff Garcia
9. Ty Detmer
10. AJ Feely