Who's gonna' be the better signing? Favre or Vick?

[brettmojo]

Money wise... The Eagles win out. But who do you think will contribute more/help their team more?

[DOHO@HOME]

Puppy lover is the better signing.
Wrangler man is old hat and should stay playing football in his back yard.

[TheGameHHH]

Favre makes Peterson and Berrian a little more intriguing, he clearly elevates their games. outside of those two i dont see him helping the Vikings all that much. I think Vick helps the Eagles as a team more then Favre helps the Vikings.

[razorboy]

Favre makes Peterson and Berrian a little more intriguing, he clearly elevates their games. outside of those two i dont see him helping the Vikings all that much. I think Vick helps the Eagles as a team more then Favre helps the Vikings.

If anything, Peterson makes Favre better. How does an elderly ballhog, blind to his own decline make AD any better?

[TooLowBrow]

theyre both in their prime. last year favre proved that even when hes not a packer that he can make a huge difference for a team. last year all vick did was bang guys and kill puppies

[RhinoinMN]

Favre is capable of putting up more scores in that QB position. Something the Vikes haven't had for a while.

I cannot answer the question.

[KingModem]

I am excited to not have to count on Tarvaris Jackson all year again.

[hammersavage]

Favre will play every offensive snap when healthy. He does get a dumb amount of money. But if he is healthy and not having to worry about weather at his age, he should help.

[Jujubees2]

Since Favre should start every game and Vick won't be eligible until the sixth week (at the earliest) I say Favre.

[Meataball23]

Farve is going to help the offense and w/ harvin running wildcat they will be improved over last year - but give me the guy who is going to play more positions/be more dynamic on a team that has a legit shot at winning the nfc

[razorboy]

Since Favre should start every game and Vick won't be eligible until the sixth week (at the earliest) I say Favre.

No, it's week six at the latest as far as I understand the suspension.

[Meataball23]

No, it's week six at the latest as far as I understand the suspension.

Youre correct

[TheGameHHH]

If anything, Peterson makes Favre better. How does an elderly ballhog, blind to his own decline make AD any better?

Peterson does make Favre better, but if you cant see how it works both ways then i cant explain it to you.

[keithy_19]

I voted for Farve, but this is coming for a Giants fan who wants the Vick experiment to crash and burn.

[TripleSkeet]

theyre both in their prime.

Lets not get crazy now.

Favre will probably have the bigger impact, at least during the regular season. But we all know when the big games come into play hes good for at least 3 picks.

[BrettFavre]

Im gonna win the superbowl just to stick it up Ted Thompson's ass

[Kevin]

Im gonna win the superbowl just to stick it up Ted Thompson's ass

How long has it gone since Epo has called you professing his love, Brett?

[BrettFavre]

How long has it gone since Epo has called you professing his love, Brett?

Who?

[benjamin]

Eagles signing Vick.

[sailor]

farve is better today, than jackson or vick (possibly better than mcnabb today as well). that, plus the ton more snaps he'll get compared to vick make this a walkover. i don't get those who took vick, unless they're looking down the road. for just this season, no contest.

[led37zep]

My calender must be wrong. Says 2009

[west milly Tom]

When Osi breaks Donovan's knee Vick will come in as backup and everyone in Philly will get selective amnesia about the whole doggy killing thing. Message board psychic

[TjM]

theyre both in their prime. last year favre proved that even when hes not a packer that he can make a huge difference for a team. last year all vick did was bang guys and kill puppies

Sounds like someone needs a truth bomb!

http://coldhardfootballfacts.com/Articles/11_2774_Favre_fantasy_vs._reality.html